Item Coversheet

Ordinances - R5  G




COMMISSION MEMORANDUM

TO:Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission 
FROM:Alina T. Hudak, City Manager 
DATE:September  14, 2022
 

10:50 a.m. Second Reading Public Hearing

SUBJECT:

R-PS1 AND R-PS2 APARTMENT HOTEL CONVERSION INCENTIVES - COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT

AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH 2040 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN RESILIENT LAND USE ELEMENT AT (1) TABLE RLU 1.1 TO PROVIDE THAT THE DENSITY AND INTENSITY LIMITS OF THE R-PS-1 AND R-PS-2 LAND USE CATEGORIES SHALL REFER TO POLICY LIMITS OF EACH RESPECTIVE CATEGORY; AT (2) POLICY RLU 1.2.22, ENTITLED “MEDIUM-LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL PERFORMANCE STANDARD (R-PS-1)” TO MODIFY DENSITY AND FLOOR AREA RATIO LIMITS OF THE R-PS-1 LAND USE CATEGORY TO INCENTIVIZE THE CONVERSION OF LEGALLY NONCONFORMING APARTMENT-HOTEL USES TO CONFORMING RESIDENTIAL USES; AND AT (3) POLICY RLU 1.2.23, ENTITLED “MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL PERFORMANCE STANDARD (R-PS-2)” TO MODIFY DENSITY AND FLOOR AREA RATIO LIMITS OF THE R-PS-2 LAND USE CATEGORY TO INCENTIVIZE THE CONVERSION OF LEGALLY NONCONFORMING APARTMENT-HOTEL USES TO CONFORMING RESIDENTIAL USES; PURSUANT TO THE EXPEDITED STATE REVIEW PROCESS IN SECTION 163.3184 (3), FLORIDA STATUTES; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, TRANSMITTAL, REPEALER, SEVERABILITY, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.


RECOMMENDATION

The Administration recommends that the City Commission adopt the subject Ordinance.

BACKGROUND/HISTORY

On September 17, 2021, at the request of Commissioner Mark Samuelian, the City Commission referred a discussion item to the Land Use and Sustainability Committee (LUSC) pertaining to quality-of-life strategies for dealing with future and existing apartment hotels in the South of Fifth area (C4G). On October 19, 2021, the LUSC discussed and continued the item to the December 2021 LUSC meeting with direction to the Administration to study potential strategic increases in FAR and height within the R-PS1 and R-PS2 districts for the limited purpose of incentivizing the conversion of existing apartment hotels to residential use.

The December 2021 LUSC meeting did not take place, and the item was automatically deferred to the first available meeting of 2022. On February 11, 2022, the LUSC discussed the proposal for strategic increases in FAR and height within the R-PS1 and R-PS2 districts and recommended that the draft Ordinance prepared by the Administration be moved to the City Commission for referral to the Planning Board. Additionally, the LUSC recommended the following:

1. The addition of an express prohibition on the short-term rental of any apartment units.

2. A 3-year sunset provision.

On March 9, 2022, the City Commission referred an LDR Ordinance, inclusive of the recommendations of the LUSC, to the Planning Board (C4B).

ANALYSIS

PLANNING ANALYSIS
The subject Ordinance amends the Resilient Land Use Element of the City’s 2040 Comprehensive Plan as follows:

Policy RLU 1.1.22 - Medium-Low Density Residential Performance Standard (R-PS-1)
• Apartment hotels are deleted as a permitted use; this is a non-substantive modification to harmonize the comprehensive plan with the LDRS. This change does not conflict with, nor supersede the LDR Amendment adopted in 2021 that prohibits apartment hotels in the R-PS1 zoning district.

• The maximum intensity (FAR) in the R-PS1 district is 1.25. The proposed Ordinance allows properties with a legally established non-conforming apartment hotel use that are converted to conforming residential uses to utilize a maximum FAR of up to 1.5.

• The current density limit in the R-PS1 district is 57 dwelling units per acre. The proposed Ordinance allows properties with a legally established non-conforming apartment hotel use that are converted to conforming residential uses to utilize a maximum density of up to 80 dwelling units per acre. This proposed density increase is to accommodate the increase in allowable intensity for properties that convert from apartment hotel use to residential use.

Policy RLU 1.1.23 - Medium Density Residential Performance Standard (R-PS-2)
• Apartment hotels are deleted as a permitted use; this is a non-substantive modification to harmonize the comprehensive plan with the LDRS. This change does not conflict with, nor supersede the LDR Amendment adopted in 2021 that prohibits apartment hotels in the R-PS1 zoning district.

• The maximum intensity (FAR) in the R-PS1 district is 1.50. The proposed Ordinance allows properties with a legally established non-conforming apartment hotel use that are converted to conforming residential uses to utilize a maximum FAR of up to 1.75.

• The current density limit in the R-PS1 district is 70 dwelling units per acre. The proposed Ordinance allows properties with a legally established non-conforming apartment hotel use that are converted to conforming residential uses to utilize a maximum density of up to 95 dwelling units per acre. This proposed density increase is to accommodate the increase in allowable intensity for properties that convert from apartment hotel use to residential use.

The subject Ordinance is a companion to a separate LDR Ordinance that amends Section 142-694 of the Land Development Regulations (LDR’s) of the City Code to create incentive provisions for the conversion of existing apartment hotels located in the R-PS1 or R-PS2 district, which are legal non-conforming, to convert to a conforming residential use. The proposed increases in density and intensity would only apply to those properties that have a legally established apartment hotel as the main permitted use, and which convert the entire property to a conforming residential use.

As noted in the attached Density and Intensity Impact Analysis, the proposed FAR and density increases could result in an additional 32 units beyond what is permitted today. This could result in an additional 26 peak hour vehicle trips taking place, assuming no trip reductions are provided for public transportation and alternative modes of transportation, which are common for this neighborhood. Given the limited scope of these amendments, the potential impacts are de minimis.

The modest and context sensitive increases in allowable FAR proposed for these limited number of properties is not expected to have a negative impact, as the maximum FAR permitted in these districts is already restricted. Since most of the apartment hotel uses in the area are in smaller, older buildings, a slight increase in allowable FAR may incentivize a re-conversion back to residential use.

Lastly, pursuant to Section 1.03(c) of the City Charter, final adoption of the Ordinance, if approved at First Reading, requires voter approval for the proposed increase in FAR.

COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING REVIEW PROCESS
This referral includes a text amendment to the Comprehensive Plan. Under Section 163.3184(2), Florida Statutes, this amendment shall follow the expedited state review process for adoption of comprehensive plan amendments. This process requires a public hearing by the local planning agency (Planning Board), a public transmittal hearing before the City Commission, after which the amendment must be transmitted to several state agencies for a 30-day review period, and a final adoption public hearing before the City Commission. The amendment is effective 31-days after it is adopted if there are no appeals.

PLANNING BOARD REVIEW
The Planning Board held a public hearing on April 26, 2022 and transmitted the Ordinance to the City Commission with a favorable recommendation (7-0).

UPDATE
On May 4, 2022, the City Commission approved the subject Ordinance at First Reading and scheduled Second Reading / Adoption for September 14, 2022, subject to voter approval of the proposed FAR increase. The Comprehensive Plan Amendment was transmitted to all applicable review agencies; to date there have been no objections or substantive comments from the review agencies.

Additionally, the City Commission adopted Resolution No. 2022-32168 to place a ballot question pertaining to the proposed FAR increase on the City’s August 23, 2022 ballot. Pursuant to Resolution No. 2022-32168, the following ballot question was submitted to the City’s voters:

RPS1 District/ RPS2 District - FAR Incentive to Convert Remaining Apartment Hotel Uses to Residential Use

City Charter requires voter approval before increasing a property's floor area ratio ("FAR") (City's method of regulating building size). In certain residential zoning districts south of 5th Street, apartment-hotels are now prohibited, but previously approved properties may continue such uses.

Shall the City increase FAR from 1.25 to 1.50 in the RPS1 District, and from 1.50 to 1.75 in the RPS2 District, to provide an incentive for converting these remaining apartment hotel uses to residential use?


On August 23, 2022, the ballot question was approved by 71.26 percent of the City’s voters. Therefore, contingent upon the certification of the election results, the subject Ordinance can be adopted by the City Commission. 

SUPPORTING SURVEY DATA

Enhance Residents Quality of Life

FINANCIAL INFORMATION

No Fiscal Impact Expected

CONCLUSION

The Administration recommends that the City Commission adopt the subject Ordinance.

Applicable Area

South Beach
Is this a "Residents Right to Know" item, pursuant to City Code Section 2-14? Does this item utilize G.O. Bond Funds?
Yes No 
Legislative Tracking
Planning
Sponsor
Vice-Mayor Alex Fernandez

ATTACHMENTS:
Description
Density and Intensity Analysis
Ordinance